Review #193. Cerain St Vain Lightning KL 17yr Rye

Whiskey Network Review #193 | /r/Bourbon Review #108: TAOS Lightning 17yr Rye, 90pf

Nose: Dull spearmint and dill notes followed by char and confectioners sugar. There’s also this funky but oddly tasty marshmallow note I’m picking up.

Taste: Mellow and sweet with only a little hint of rye spice. No dill to speak of here and an odd orchard fruitiness. Apples and strawberries and cream with some faint clove and a modest helping of punchy rye. It’s balanced but far fruitier and sweet than I’d expect given the age.

Finish: Medium, fudgey and spicy. Here’s that rye spice. Some cherry cola notes, still no dill and only faintly minty. Sweet, fruity and unique.

Overall: This one took me a long time to figure out. I initially went back and forth because this dram throws a lot at you. Fruits, sweets, then spice, then sweet, then dill, then spice. All over the place. Eventually though, after savoring it all, I realized I liked it a great deal. I wish it was punchier and more bold but for what it was, I really found myself enjoying every sip. For this reason, I’m giving it a Rank 7 rating. This might shock some of you – it certainly surprised me at the end how much I missed it when it was gone. With a rating like this, the TAOS 17yr Rye sits among High West Rendezvous Rye, WhistlePig 10yr rye and SAOS 7yr Rye. Thanks for reading!

Thanks for reading!

Rank: 7

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.